«Pesticides are becoming increasingly toxic»

«Pesticides are becoming increasingly toxic»

This is the opposite of the truth. Over the last few decades, pesticides have become safer and safer. New active ingredients are subjected to extremely stringent approval processes. The governing principle is that they must not harm people or the environment if used properly. Developments reflect this: the data available demonstrates that, over the last twenty years, pesticides have become not only safer but also more environmentally friendly.

Wednesday, March 31, 2021

The key points in brief

  • Fewer and fewer pesticides with potential associated risks are being approved and sold.
  • The acute toxicity of pesticides has diminished. At the same time, the quantities of active ingredients required to produce the same level of protection are also down.
  • The statement that pesticides are becoming increasingly toxic does not reflect the facts.

Opponents of pesticides are happy to give the impression that «pesticides are becoming increasingly toxic». But this is misleading. A range of data proves that enormous progress has been made since the 1960s. The quantities of active ingredients used per hectare has decreased by 90 percent since 1962. Back then, a farmer would have had to apply 10 kilograms of an active ingredient per hectare, while now this is reduced to less than 1 kilogram.

Increasingly safe products

At the same time, newly developed active ingredients have become increasingly safe. This is reflected in statistics from the World Health Organisation (WHO). They split pesticides into four safety categories: Class 1: Extremely hazardous; Class 2: Moderately hazardous; Class 3, Slightly hazardous, Class U: Not hazardous. As of 2000, Class 1 agents can no longer be approved. Half of all new pesticides approved are Class U. Acute toxicity has decreased by 40 percent since the 1960s.

Blindspot article

Large-scale sustainable food production and healthy eating are complex topics. They need to be viewed from different perspectives. Yet unpopular facts are all too often given short shrift in the public discussion. We illuminate the topics that usually remain in the shadows. This makes it possible for people with conflicting views to engage in a dialogue.

The risks are falling

This development is also reflected in the Department for Agriculture’s pesticide sales statistics. These show that the sale of high-risk pesticides for conventional agriculture has fallen 35 percent over the last ten years. The proportion of high-risk pesticides among the total amount sold is eleven percent. At 34 percent, the most widespread ingredient by some margin is copper, which is also used in organic farming. The risks of using pesticides in conventional farming have been dropping steadily for years. The trend is moving in the right direction.

Related articles

Tradition and innovation go hand in hand when it comes to food
Knowledge

Tradition and innovation go hand in hand when it comes to food

The study ‘Decoding Food Culture’ by the Gottlieb Duttweiler Institute shows how deeply food culture shapes our lives. That is why it is a balancing act between tradition and innovation to bring about changes in nutrition.

The underestimated danger of plant toxins
Knowledge

The underestimated danger of plant toxins

Plants produce a variety of chemical substances to protect themselves against predators and diseases, for example. These substances can have a toxic effect in high doses. A recent study by Agroscope highlights the danger of natural substances in Swiss waters.

Natural is naturally dangerous – Why the plant's own poisons are underestimated
Knowledge

Natural is naturally dangerous – Why the plant's own poisons are underestimated

Many believe that natural foods are safer than those with synthetic pesticides. But plants produce their own poisons – and these are often just as risky. While artificial residues are regulated, natural defences are largely ignored. A fallacy, as scientist Bruce Ames shows.

Confidence in breakthrough technologies
Knowledge

Confidence in breakthrough technologies

A global survey of 13,000 people in 13 countries shows that people are fundamentally positive about new technologies. The study also reveals a clear correlation between knowledge and attitude: the more people know about a technology, the more positively they view it.

More contributions from Knowledge